Damian Maggio on Option Pools: How Employee Equity Shapes Ownership in a Funding Round

Originally published at damianmaggio.com.

By Damian Maggio

When a private company announces a valuation, the headline number rarely tells the whole story about who owns what afterward. One term that moves ownership more than many people expect is the employee option pool.

An option pool is a block of shares set aside for future grants to employees and other service providers. It helps a young company recruit people who might otherwise prefer a larger company's salary. Because the shares are reserved before they are granted, they show up in the company's fully diluted share count even though no one holds them yet.

Cooley GO, the startup resource from the law firm Cooley, explains how the pool is usually framed in a financing. It typically represents a percentage of the company's fully diluted capitalization after the investment closes. Most investors, Cooley GO says, require that full amount to be treated as part of the capitalization before the closing when the price per share is calculated. That means the pool dilutes the existing holders, not the new shares.

This is why practitioners sometimes say the pool can matter as much as the valuation. Cooley GO makes the point that founders may be better off at a lower valuation with a smaller pool than at a higher valuation with a larger one. Its worked example compares a $15 million pre-money valuation with a 20 percent pool against a $12 million pre-money valuation with a 15 percent pool. The share counts and ownership percentages come out differently in each case, even though both are described as "a priced round."

The law firm Brown Rudnick makes a related observation. It notes that including the pool in the pre-money valuation can create an illusory increase in the headline number. In its example, a $5 million pre-money valuation that includes a 20 percent pool effectively values the outstanding equity at $4 million. Brown Rudnick adds that there is nothing inherently wrong with that structure, but it has real economic effects that are worth understanding.

How large should a pool be? Brown Rudnick cites data from Carta indicating that at the time of a seed or Series A financing, a company will typically have an available pool equal to 10 to 20 percent of its fully diluted capital right after the financing. It says the main factor should be the company's hiring needs until the next financing, typically over the next 12 to 24 months. Cooley GO suggests building an option budget from the hires planned over the next 12 to 18 months, which can produce a smaller and more credible number than a generic percentage.

For anyone looking at a private company from the outside, the takeaway is simple. Ask what share of the fully diluted count is held in the pool, whether it was counted before or after the new money, and how much of it has already been granted.

Option pools are one factor among many. Private company shares are illiquid and may be impossible to sell for years. Information is limited, there is no market price, and valuations are uncertain. Future rounds and pool increases can dilute existing holders, and investors can lose their entire investment.

Damian Maggio writes about private markets and technology. More at damianmaggio.com. This article is for informational purposes only and is not an offer or recommendation to buy or sell any security.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Damian Maggio on Tender Offers: How Late-Stage Private Companies Create Liquidity

Damian Maggio on Direct Listings vs. IPOs: Two Ways a Private Company Goes Public

Damian Maggio: Why Cybersecurity Has Become a Core Diligence Question