Damian Maggio on Direct Listings vs. IPOs: Two Ways a Private Company Goes Public
Originally published at damianmaggio.com
People often use "going public" as if it describes a single process. In my roughly 30 years in securities and private investment, I have seen that there are several paths, and the differences matter for company insiders and for anyone trading the shares afterward.
The SEC publishes a plain-language comparison of the main routes. Two of them are the traditional IPO and the direct listing.
The traditional IPO. According to the SEC, a private company raises capital by selling newly issued shares to investment banks, the underwriters, which then sell them primarily to institutional investors. The SEC notes that companies may choose this path to have more control over their initial investor base and to get an underwriter's help marketing the shares and managing early trading volume. It also notes that transaction costs, including underwriter fees, are high and the process typically takes a long time.
The direct listing. In the SEC's description, a private company becomes public, typically without raising new funds, by allowing existing shareholders to sell their shares directly to the public. There is no underwriter selling the stock. The SEC says that historically a few very large, consumer-facing companies have used this path, partly because of potentially lower transaction costs.
Where they differ. The SEC's comparison chart points to a few differences. An IPO raises new capital and typically dilutes existing shareholders. A direct listing typically does not. An IPO commonly carries a lockup of about 180 days for existing holders, while a direct listing typically has none.
What to consider. With no underwriters, the SEC says, a company has no control over its initial investor base and may face trading volume challenges. That is why direct listings tend to suit companies with strong brand recognition that can draw enough market interest on their own.
What it means for holders. Employees and early investors in a company going public should read the registration documents closely. Whether shares are locked up, when they can be sold and how the first price is set all depend on the path chosen. Neither route removes the risks of owning a newly listed stock. Prices can swing widely, and a stock can trade below where it started.
The right question is not which route is better in the abstract. It is which route a particular company chose, why, and what that means for the supply of shares in the first months of trading.
Damian Maggio writes about private markets and technology. This article is for informational purposes only and is not an offer or recommendation to buy or sell any security.
Comments
Post a Comment